Charter · Buffalo, New York · 200 students

One-on-one math tutoring for every single 3rd through 5th grader

“Third Space Learning is a much more interactive and responsive math practice opportunity than anything else available to us. It’s not just practice, it’s targeted to exactly what each student needs, at every level.”

One-on-one math tutoring for every single 3rd through 5th grader
Madeline Loeb, Director of Curriculum and Instruction Primary Hall Charter School, Buffalo, New York
$5,000 a year, unlimited sessions with Skye
683 one-on-one sessions attended
77 students given one-on-one tutoring
84% of confidence check-outs ended as or more confident
High-dosage tutoring typically costs $1,000 to over $3,000 a student. Primary Hall put 77 students through one-on-one tutoring at $5,000 a year, around $65 a student.
TSL platform data, Mar 2026 to Sep 2026 · confidence: students say how confident they feel at the end of each session · cost: the school’s TSL subscription · benchmark: Stanford NSSA District Playbook for High-Impact Tutoring
The challenge

Our state test scores in math weren’t where we wanted them to be

Our school opened a few years ago and now serves 200 students. With a strong ELA program in place, we turned our attention to math and set out to find an intervention that could provide the targeted, individualized support our students needed. Our state test scores in math weren’t where we wanted them to be. That’s why we started looking for an intervention.

I came across Third Space Learning while making test prep materials for one of our teachers. I found a worksheet online and thought, I wonder if they have more – and when I saw the tutoring, I thought, oh wow, this is amazing. I looked at other curriculum resources, but I didn’t see anything comparable for a math tutoring program. The ability to scale the tutoring, and Skye’s ability to respond on the fly to students’ misconceptions, were the key things I saw.

The decision

The overall feeling from parents was relief and excitement

When I saw it was an AI tutor, I personally didn’t have reservations. I felt comfortable with the model and the safety precautions in place. Math is an area where parents can feel unsure about how to support their children at home, and teachers are managing such a broad range of abilities that targeted support is hard to provide.

When we introduced Third Space Learning, I shared information with parents about how it worked and linked directly to the safety protocols on the TSL website. There were no concerns at all. The overall feeling from both parents and staff was just relief and excitement that we now had something in place to address that.

The set-up

Every single 3rd through 5th grader, almost every day

We rolled it out to all of our 3rd through 5th grade students, every single one. With an in-person tutoring program, you can only serve a limited number of students, and if a child is absent the day a tutor comes in, that’s a wasted session. There are no complications like that with Third Space Learning.

To get started, I pulled a small group of students to test it out and get comfortable with it, then trained our school volunteers so they could help oversee sessions and troubleshoot for students. From there, teachers took the lead with their own classes. Students use Skye almost every day, around 30 minutes at a time, mostly during independent blocks in the school day, like when a teacher is working with a small group or during breakfast. We’ve also run after-school and Saturday open sessions so families can come in and watch their child use it, which has been really well received.

What changed

I can see the difference before the data

We track student growth using NWEA MAP assessments, and I’ve been really eager to see the results after this year’s sessions. But even before the data, I can see the difference. Students are growing in their confidence and bringing that with them into classroom instruction. They can take the skills they’ve been working on with Skye and apply them in class. Having that extra practice going into state tests really built them up.

There are certainly students who feel far more confident speaking with Skye than they do in a classroom setting. I’ve noticed a real difference in the willingness to try things and make mistakes. I can see it in the confidence reports on the platform too – scores going up, and the little comments students leave for Skye tell their own story.

“Seeing the students really engaged, enjoying their lessons, and seeing their confidence grow. That has been the biggest highlight.”

The main benefit for us has been the ability to provide differentiated, targeted support to every student. The support from the team has been really helpful too. Any time we had a tech issue, I’d get on the chat and the team would respond promptly and helpfully. It was very easy to use and set up. I wish I had found this a lot sooner.

Madeline Loeb, Director of Curriculum and Instruction, Primary Hall Charter School
Download the PDF version of this case study

Watch a session in action

See how Skye guides students through a full one-on-one session.

Read more case studies

Fairfax Multi Academy Trust logo
Fairfax Multi Academy Trust
Birmingham · Secondary

“One fixed cost, four schools, and tutoring for every pupil on the intervention list”

Natalie Thompson, Academy Improvement Advisor for Maths and Numeracy
Measured impactMulti-academy trustGCSE results
Read case study →
St Giles Church of England Primary School logo
St Giles Church of England Primary School
Walsall · Primary

“From 59 pupils to 182 across Years 4 to 6, built into every maths lesson”

Simrat Mavi, Deputy Headteacher and SEND Lead
Pupil PremiumSENDFits the school day
Read case study →
De Lacy Primary School logo
De Lacy Primary School
Pontefract · Primary

“From 15 targeted pupils to the whole Year 6 cohort of 44, on one fixed cost”

Connor McMahon, Assistant Headteacher and Maths Lead
SATs resultsPupil PremiumMaths confidence
Read case study →

Would this work in your school or district?

Primary Hall is a 200-student charter school in Buffalo, New York.
Tell us your numbers and we will show you what the same approach covers in a school or district your size.

Request a tutoring quote for your school or district

Tell us about your school or district and we’ll show you what unlimited one-on-one math tutoring with Skye, our AI math tutor, could look like for your students.

Math tutoring trusted by 4,200+ schools since 2013

Unlimited one-on-one tutoring for one low fixed cost

Developed by math teachers for maximum academic impact

Built using insights from 2,295,000+ one-on-one tutoring sessions

You can learn more about how we keep your data safe and secure in our privacy policy.