Using bar modelling techniques to solve multi-step KS2 SATs problems

By That Boy Can Teach 

Discover how @thatboycanteach has started using Singapore style bar modelling techniques with his Year 6 class to solve multi-step KS2 SATs problems in Key Stage 2 Maths. Try it out in your lessons to build reasoning, fluency and problem solving skills.

Bar Modelling is taking the primary maths world by storm. The 2014 national curriculum appears, despite initial unhappiness, to be achieving a shift in the way maths is taught. Its three main aims of reasoning, problem solving and fluency have encouraged teachers to seek further ways to encourage conceptual understanding, rather than just teaching tricks or rules.

So teachers have looked towards the countries who apparently churn out mastery-level mathematicians by the thousands for inspiration - that or some savvy publishers have decided to capitalise on the desire of teachers to teach the 'why' rather than the 'how'.

What is Singapore Maths-style Bar Modelling?

Hailing from Singapore, with its champion being Dr. Yeap Ban Har, the bar modelling approach seeks to provide a visual for the inner workings of maths problems. There are plenty of places to find out more about how it works if you've not yet come across it. I'd recommend the Maths - No Problem! Youtube channel, the White Rose Hub trainingNick Hart's blog and another Third Space Learning blog post which gives you the basics.

While Bar Modelling can be used to model some quite complex problems (pictured below - a comparative bar model), there are opportunities to use very basic part-whole bar modelling skills to represent multi-step worded problems.

Having only introduced bar modelling to year 6 recently I wanted to find a way to make their new-found skills useful in their approach to answering SATs problems.

Free Download:

25 Year 6 Addition and Subtraction SATs Questions to Practise Bar Modelling

 

Nick Hart's approach to using bar modelling for problem solving is foundational to the approach I've been trialing. His blog post 'Throwing Out That Old RUCSAC' outlines three different underlying structures for word problems: whole unknown, size of parts unknown and number of parts unknown. He provides this useful image to demonstrate:

All of the given examples are of 1 step problems but all similar problems in the KS2 tests have at least 2 steps, some of them have 3 or 4. Having grasped the use of bar models for 1 step problems, I wanted to give the children a way to use their skills for multi-step problems.

Mastering Multi-step Bar Modelling

Essentially, any worded problem, regardless of number of steps, is a series of one step problems; children just need to identify the number of steps and the processes that need to be undertaken at each step. I say 'just', but that's where most children struggle - very often children will complete some of the necessary steps, but not all of them. This was another reason to attempt to provide children with a structured approach to solving these kinds of problem.

And this is what I came up with:

You will note the initial question: What will my answer look like?

This encourages children to think about what their final answer will look like before they embark on the working out and provides a checking point to refer to throughout the exercise: after each step, children write a sentence explaining what they have worked out so far and then match it up to their answer to the question what will my answer look like? If they don't match, then they know that they need to continue to work.

For each step in creating the bar model children are also encouraged to:

  • Draw a bar model to represent just that step
  • Identify the underlying structure
  • Identify the operation
  • Complete the working out
  • Write a summary of what they have worked out so far (as mentioned above)

In order to provide initial support we provided a little extra scaffolding to begin with by giving a brief outline of what must be done to complete each part/step of the problem:

These outlines can be made even more explicit. Taking the above example, part 1 could say: divide the cost of the bag of lemons by the number of lemons to find out how much each lemon costs.

The idea with this is, of course, that eventually this whole scaffold will be removed and children will be able to visualise these types of problems without even having to draw bar models, although there is nothing wrong with a child drawing a bar model in the SATs, for example. In order to support this, we have adapted the grid to remove the necessity for a bar model (although some children do still choose to draw them):

Using this approach, albeit for a very short amount of time, many children, particularly those who have previously struggled with solving these kinds of problems, have begun to confidently and successfully work through these kinds of problems.

It is worth mentioning that not all SATs problems can be solved using this process. This is could be one of a range of strategies children use during the tests. As such, there are further opportunities for children to practise identifying the types of question that can be answered in this way. However, initially teachers will need to provide particular examples, like these scaffolded Bar Model Maths questions or these which I uploaded to the TES website as a free download. Whilst this approach is more suited to KS2 work, there are also two-step problems in the KS1 SATs.

Worked examples of Bar Modelling Techniques 

Finally, some (scruffy) worked examples: 

Third Space Learning and @thatboycanteach would love to hear your thoughts on this approach - are there further opportunities for development? Is there anything missing that would further support understanding of the problem solving process? Tweet us at @thirdspacetweet, and @thatboycanteach!

Free trial mobile b4758577c38650132e9d11ce43fc5c123ab51dc419251615cb46c21a78dc3cef Get Started

Put two of your pupils on our
1-to-1 tuition for free.

We think they'll love it, but
know you'll want to see it in practice before making a decision.